Madison has played for five years on nationally-ranked volleyball teams - ASEVC Premier, Brooklyn Elite Volleyball and NYC Juniors. She is a Defensive Specialist (DS) and Setter. Her team has represented the Northeast Region in the USAV Nationals in 2019 and 2023. In the 2022-23 season, her ASEVC 15 Premier team was ranked in the 40s of over 4000 teams nationally. Madison has also been the starting setter for Hoboken High School's varsity volleyball team since freshman year.

Over her varsity volleyball career, she has delivered 870 assists, 337 digs, 417 service points, 169 aces and 59 kills.